Survey

Several films disappointed at the Box Office this summer (2016). Which was the most surprising?


Alice Through the Looking Glass

Ben-Hur

The BFG

Ghostbusters

Ice Age: Collision Course

Independence Day: Resurgence

The Legend of Tarzan

Now You See Me 2

Pete's Dragon

Popstar: Never Stop Never Stopping

Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Out of the Shadows

Warcraft

X-Men: Apocalypse

Other











The Word of Mouth for Gods and Generals


poster
Total Entries: 124 Overall Rating:
Overall Recommendation Stars Total Votes Percent
Instant Classic: 47   38%
Really Good: 14   11%
OK: 7   6%
Bad: 8   6%
Really Bad: 17   14%
Among Worst Ever: 31   25%
Breakdown
Males Under 25
Males 25 and Over
Females Under 25
Females 25 and Over
Everyone
Stars
Percent
Percent
Percent
Percent
Percent
  52%   36%   38%   19%   38%
  11%   16%   12%   6%   11%
  7%   5%   0%   6%   6%
  2%   5%   25%   6%   6%
  4%   16%   12%   38%   14%
  24%   23%   12%   25%   25%
Category Averages
Action
Acting
Comedy
FX
Story



Post Your Rating for Gods and Generals



Nickname
Your Gender:
Male:
Female:
Your Age Group:
Under 25:
25 or Older:
Would you recommend this movie?
poster
Your Recommendation:
Instant Classic:
Really Good:
OK:
Bad:
Really Bad:
Among Worst Ever:
No comment,
I already voted
or I haven't seen it
Break it Down
Breakdown Ratings:
Acting:
Action:
Comedy:
Special Effects:
Story:

Post Your Review of Gods and Generals
Please use the board below to post your review and comments about Gods and Generals.

Report a problem or objectionable post here

comments powered by Disqus
Other Reviews for Gods and Generals
Total Entries : 135
Now showing entries 135 through 126
Post # 135
Date 8/4/2007 - 10:41 PM
Name Jim in charlotte.
Rating:
Comments: A well acted, historically accurate film of jackson and the events leading up to gettysburg. sincerely hope that some day the "directors cut" will be available on dvd and at the same time hope that roger ebert chokes on his review. .
Post # 134
Breakdown
Acting
No Rating
Action
No Rating
Comedy
No Rating
Effects
Story
No Rating
Date 1/11/2007 - 12:52 AM
Name Big dave.
Rating:
Comments: Good movie. Wwish they make a second part about robert e. Lee.
Post # 133
Date 9/26/2006 - 12:33 PM
Name . .
Rating:
Comments: Where's the director's cut?.
Post # 132
Breakdown
Acting
No Rating
Action
No Rating
Comedy
Effects
No Rating
Story
No Rating
Date 3/31/2006 - 1:41 PM
Name Unionman.
Rating:
Comments: This is one of the worst, if not the worst, civil war movies ever to hit the screen. the battle scenes are laughable-bloodless reenactments, and its makers would like you to believe that stonewall jackson was a kindly, almost grandfatherly, man. if you find this film to be historically accurate, you need to do a little more reading. this is not what these men were like. this is not what civil war era combat was like. this is a horrible horrible horrible "film. " .
Post # 131
Date 3/24/2006 - 6:09 AM
Name Miko.
Rating:
Comments: Historically accurate, perhaps, but a highly sanitized version of history. Very cliche, badly directed and very poorly written. There was one of two moments with some good cinematography, though, but they were few and far between. It was a struggle not to turn it off before the end. awful! .
Post # 130
Date 10/31/2005 - 9:05 AM
Name Reenactor enthusiast.
Rating:
Comments: I really enjoyed the dvd. The movie showed me the accuracy of the major battles from 1861-1863. Iam ahistory buff; esp. Cw history. I am a yank who grew up in va. They are my boys; esp. The irish brigade. I like jackson's faith and sense of duty. It was accuratly showen in the movie. I don't enjoy critics who pan a movie based on their personal bises. G and g was not based on race; but duty to one's state as seen in the 1900's. The 20th maine felt the same. The pa. Volunteers felt the same. The unionists felt the same. And so on. It mayn't seem so about unionists; but why volunteer if not so? .
Post # 129
Date 10/30/2005 - 5:46 AM
Name Sixstrings.
Rating:
Comments: This is the greatest civil war movie ever!! only those oblivious to american culture and history (i would say domestically that is more prevelant) would have disdain for a movie that accurately describes the first two and a half years of the war between the states!!.
Post # 128
Date 10/4/2005 - 11:08 PM
Name new guy
Rating:
Comments: I love civil war movies mainly b/c i'm a civil war reenactor to. I can't belvie people well say that gods and generals sucks well u just don't know any thing about the civil war maybe that's why if you are a history buff about any thing this is a good one spcially if you are a cw buff. the battle scenes are acruittly correct just like in gettysburg movie. The time line and speaches are correct and it is verry well edited can't wait tell the 6 hour verison other know as directors cut who cares if it was 3 hours and 35 minutes long lord of the rings return of the king ran to be 3 hours and 12 minutes just as long almost. Same with pearl harbor with ben aflack worst movie ever made about usa war history by hollywood that was 4 hours long. So what now gods and generals deserves all the stars and respect it can get after it went threw and now ted turner should produce the "the last full measure" come on ted turner get off your ass there are people who want the movie to be made and seen on big screen. Please!.
Post # 127
Date 11/12/2004 - 6:41 AM
Name Court s. .
Rating:
Comments: We had to watch it in school. . . . Nobody liked it but a few!.
Post # 126
Breakdown
Acting
Action
No Rating
Comedy
No Rating
Effects
No Rating
Story
No Rating
Date 9/19/2004 - 10:23 PM
Name .Amanda
Rating:
Comments: All those people who thought this movie sucked obviously would rather watch mindless action flicks then see a good historically accurate movie. Definitely a classic. .


Go To


Gods and Generals Stuff
[Poster ] [ Amazon DVD] [ Amazon Book]
Movies of 2003
Movie Overall Rating
X2: X-Men United
LOTR: The Return of the King
Finding Nemo
Honey
Pirates of the Caribbean
The Last Samurai
Terminator 3: Rise of the Machines
Big Fish
Out of Time
The Italian Job
Seabiscuit
Radio
Master and Commander
Matchstick Men
Underworld
Love Actually
Wrong Turn
Monster
Sinbad: Legend of the Seven Seas
Freaky Friday
Daredevil
Something's Gotta Give
Grind
How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days
Identity
Holes
The Hulk
Old School
Bruce Almighty
The School of Rock
The Matrix: Reloaded
Tears of the Sun
Bad Santa
Basic
Cheaper by the Dozen
The Recruit
Daddy Day Care
S.W.A.T.
Bad Boys II
The Life of David Gale
Anger Management
Elf
Stuck on You
Cold Mountain
Open Range
Timeline
Tupac: Resurrection
Duplex
The Matrix Revolutions
Kill Bill Volume 1
Gods and Generals
Phone Booth
What a Girl Wants
Confidence
The Rundown
Lara Croft Tomb Raider 2
Freddy vs. Jason
Runaway Jury
The Texas Chainsaw Massacre
Once Upon a Time in Mexico
American Wedding
Lost in Translation
Final Destination 2
A Man Apart
Cradle 2 the Grave
The League of Extraordinary Gentlemen
The Fighting Temptations
Dickie Roberts: Former Child Star
Jeepers Creepers 2
The Core
Bringing Down the House
Love Don't Cost a Thing
Under the Tuscan Sun
Secondhand Lions
Agent Cody Banks
The Jungle Book 2
The Order
Hollywood Homicide
Spy Kids 3D: Game Over
Shanghai Knights
Down with Love
28 Days Later
2 Fast 2 Furious
Dark Blue
Gothika
How to Deal
Brother Bear
A Guy Thing
Uptown Girls
The Lizzie McGuire Movie
The Haunted Mansion
Bulletproof Monk
Marci X
Scary Movie 3
Johnny English
Paycheck
The Missing
Head of State
Darkness Falls
Just Married
Beyond Borders
Looney Tunes: Back in Action
Malibu's Most Wanted
Kangaroo Jack
Willard
Mystic River
Biker Boyz
Intolerable Cruelty
National Security
House of 1,000 Corpses
Calendar Girls
Rugrats Go Wild
Good Boy!
Boat Trip
Alex and Emma
Deliver Us From Eva
The In-Laws
Mona Lisa Smile
Dreamcatcher
Legally Blonde 2: Red, White and Blonde
The Medallion
Piglet's Big Movie
It Runs in The Family
The Hunted
In the Cut
Chasing Papi
Gigli
Bend It Like Beckham
Charlie's Angels: Full Throttle
View from the Top
Dumb and Dumberer: When Harry Met Lloyd
Cold Creek Manor
My Boss's Daughter
A Mighty Wind
The Cat in the Hat
The Real Cancun
House of the Dead
Cabin Fever
From Justin to Kelly




Questions, Suggestions, Comments????